Journal Entry #1
Tahsin Khan
English 21003, Section M
Professor Matyakubova
5 September 2017
Journal Entry #1
“Battling Bad Science” Ben Goldacre
While watching Ben Goldacre’s TED Talk for “Battling Bad Science,” it brought light upon newspapers and magazines creating random treatments, facts and what he mentioned “Bad Science” that many people do not notice or are naïve enough to believe. For example, he mentioned that a magazine said that coffee can cause cancer but it can also prevent cancer. Another text mentioned housework can prevent breast cancer or shopping makes a man more impotent. I found it really hilarious how editors even let things like that be published especially without proper evidence. Also, sometimes they just sound ridiculous, it makes me wonder why people believe it. Most of the time, the treatments they impose favor one gender, or lifestyle or more. It’s extremely bias to other things as well as incredibly inaccurate. Although they do have some truth to them sometimes, aren’t they afraid of when it goes wrong? What would they do if these companies were blamed for some of the things they advertise? Something that I thought about while he was speaking about “Bad Science” are the life hacks that go around on Facebook and Instagram and basically any type of social media. For example, coke hacks: cleaning things with coke. It’s interesting to how people believe it even though it probably doesn’t work.
Another thing that Ben Goldacre mentioned is placebo’s in trials. I found this really interesting because it’s amazing how much belief comes into selling things. Coming from a program called Science Research, I know all about trials and how you have to be accurate and make sure you don’t “cheat” with your data. It’s true that a lot of scientists or entrepreneurs try to make their product look better by making the competition look bad. But these people heavily rely on placebos, they try to convince people to believe that it will work which defines what placebos are. When a person genuinely believes that a medication will help them or cure them, it persuades them to believe a medication or product works. However, I do believe that placebos should exist, I do think it’s not right in trials when they try to guarantee a product is better than their competition by giving the other one’s higher doses so there’s more side effects and a lower dosage for the product there trying to sell so it has less side effects. I learned that in order to have an accurate trial, everything has to be the same or else another variable is added.
Comments
Post a Comment