Journal Entry #10
Tahsin Khan
Writing for the Sciences
Professor Matyakubova
21 November 2017
Journal #10
The Perils of Obedience
In this
article, Stanley Milgram talks about the study he conducted where majority of
people would go against their own decisions of right or wrong to appease the
requests of an authority figure. Milgram states, “Obedience is as basic an
element in the structure of social life as one can point to.” Submission to an
authority figure goes way back to earlier times. I think the way he went about
it was a little crazy but it was cool at the same time. In the experiment one
was a teacher and one was a learner. The learner was strapped to an electric
chair and for each wrong answer the electric shocks get stronger and stronger.
The experiment showed that majority of people would shock the learner into the
danger zone but nothing past that. Some of the results showed that the teacher
in the experiment would choose the lowest or painless level. Milgram states "The
essence of obedience is that a person comes to view himself as the instrument
for carrying out another person’s wishes, and he therefore no longer regards
himself as responsible for his actions."(108)
To me, I
am obedient when it comes to school and stuff. For example, I wouldn’t
willingly disobey by teacher because I believe they don’t need that especially
since they already have to deal with difficult kids. I would also change my
answers or behave a certain way to appeal to an authority figure, especially if
I like them or I want a good grade. When it comes to family, I’m a little more
rebellious but it’s never too much. This experiment in my opinion seems a
little harsh but at least he got some good results out of it.
Comments
Post a Comment